| The treatment of Rape Trauma
Syndrome using acupuncture and herbs as an adjunct to traditional
responses is a newly emerging therapeutic approach worthy of
exploration. Rape Trauma Syndrome was first discussed in 1974 in the
American Journal of Psychiatry by psychiatrist Ann Wolbert Burgess and
sociologist Lynda Lytle Holmstrom who interviewed and followed 146
patients admitted to the emergency ward with a presenting complaint of
having been raped.1 The symptoms of Rape Trauma
Syndrome share some similarities to Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
(PTSD).
PTSD was first recognized as a psychiatric
disorder in the third edition of the American Psychiatric Association's
(APA) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (1980). The
current criteria, in the fourth edition of this manual (DSMIV; APA,
1994), define PTSD as a syndrome comprising three clusters of signs and
symptoms:
- repeated reexperience of the trauma (e.g.,
intrusive recollections of the event, nightmares);
- emotional numbing (e.g., difficulty
experiencing positive emotions) and avoidance of activities and stimuli
reminiscent of the trauma; and
- heightened arousal (e.g., exaggerated startle
reflex, insomnia; night terrors)
- Finally, a diagnosis of PTSD requires that
these symptoms still be evident at least 1 month after trauma exposure
and cause impairment or clinically significant distress.
The description of Rape Trauma Syndrome overlaps
these findings, but
also presents some unique characteristics. Wolbert and Holstrom
describe what they observe to be a two-phase reaction. Based on their
observations, they found women's Impact Reactions to be fairly equally
distributed between the Expressed style: (fear, anger, anxiety, crying
sobbing) and Controlled style (emotions presenting as masked, hidden,
composed or subdued). Common somatic reactions during the first few
weeks following a rape may include physical trauma, skeletal muscle
tension, gastrointestinal irritability, genitourinary disturbance.
Emotional reactions included a wide gamut of feelings including fear,
humiliation, embarrassment, anger, revenge, self-blame.
Long-term reactions involved reorganization of the
victim's life as a result of the rape. This included any combination of
the following: moving residences, changing phone numbers, traveling
away to other states or countries, turning to support to family members
not normally seen on a regular basis. Patients coped in different ways
regarding the trauma depending upon their ego strength, social network
support, and the way they were treated by others as a response to their
victimization.
Other long-term reactions based on Wolbert and
Holstrom's findings include: nightmares, the development of various
phobias related to the trauma, such as: fear of indoors, fear of
outdoors, fear of being alone, fear of crowds, fear of people behind
them. Additionally, patients reported fears and crisis in their sexual
life. Additionally, some patients had what is called Compounded
Reactions. In such cases the trauma of rape was preceded by existing
physical, social, psychiatric, or unresolved past sexual assault/sexual
abuse histories. In such circumstances, the tendency for depression,
psychotic behavior, alcoholism, drug abuse, acting out behavior or
suicidal behavior was increased.
The usage of "Rape Trauma Syndrome" to describe
the constellation of symptoms experienced by victims has become
accepted by national and international organizations that deal with the
topic, such as RAINN (Rape and Incest National Network.2),
Planned
Parenthood and rape crisis centers worldwide.
Many of the psycho-emotional and somatic symptoms
of Rape Trauma Syndrome easily translate to the diagnostic language of
Oriental Medicine, and can be treated with the methods and modalities
of the same as we will explore in this paper.
Oriental Medicine (OM), also known as Chinese
Medicine or Traditional Chinese Medicine, is one of the world's oldest
systems of medicine. It is a sophisticated system that has been refined
for thousands of years and its use predates the birth of Christ. Unlike
some forms of medicine, OM treats both the root (the cause) of a
disease as well as its symptoms. The objective in Oriental Medicine is
to restore balance in the body based on elemental paradigms developed
from observation of nature. In Oriental Medicine, all diseases are seen
as a departure from homeostasis and the treatment objective is to
restore balance and proper functioning of the various organ systems of
the body, which results in the relief of physical pain and emotional
distress and the restoration of spiritual harmony. Oriental Medicine
encompasses a variety of therapies including acupuncture, herbal
medicine, dietary therapy, Tui Na medical massage, and Qi Gong (life
force cultivation exercises).
In the past two decades, acupuncture has grown in
popularity in the United States. According to the 2002 National Health
Interview Survey 3--the largest and most
comprehensive survey of Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM)
use by Americans to date, an estimated 8.2 million U.S. adults had ever
used acupuncture, and an estimated 2.1 million U.S. adults had ever
used acupuncture the year before.
The rise in popularity of this form of medicine is
further evidenced by the incorporation of acupoints into various
contemporary healing modalities. Some examples are EFT - Emotional
Freedom Technique®4, TAT -Tapas Acupressure
Technique®5, the Tara Approach for healing
shock and trauma 6 and Zero Balancing®7 to name a few. The emergence of these therapies
indicates that there is a therapeutic effect achieved from the
stimulation of acupoints, when used alone, or in conjunction with
verbal processing.
With the growth in popularity of Oriental Medicine
as a treatment modality, more and more studies have been conducted
according to the formal scientific model, which demonstrate the
efficacy of acupuncture in treating a variety of conditions that are
commonly associated with Post Traumatic Stress and/or Rape Trauma
Syndrome.
Several studies suggest that acupuncture may treat
conditions and symptoms such as depression, anxiety and insomnia that
are not uncommon among Rape Trauma Syndrome sufferers. A University of
Arizona Study concluded that from a small sample of 38 women who
received acupuncture, 1/3 who received depression-specific treatment,
1/3 who received treatment not specific to depression and 1/3 who were
waitlisted for the duration of the study, but received
depression-specific treatment later, the first group obtained
significant symptom relief, at rates comparable to those of
psychotherapy or pharmacotherapy.8
A Yale University School of Medicine study found
that acupuncture can be an effective treatment for chronic anxiety
disorders. The study used 55 healthy volunteers, all of whom received
bilateral auricular acupuncture. 1/3 were needled on the "relaxation"
point, 1/3 were needled on "Shenmen" which is also known for it's
calming effect, and 1/3 received needles in a sham point. The
researchers concluded that auricular acupuncture at the "relaxation"
point can decrease the anxiety level in a population of healthy
volunteers.9
A 2004 Canadian study at the Centre for Addiction
and Mental Health found that of 18 adult subjects with anxiety
complicated by insomnia experienced significant improvements in sleep
quality after 5 weeks of acupuncture treatment.10
A Maine study assessed outcomes of 25 patients in
long-term mental health counseling who combined counseling with a
complementary therapy of their choice; either massage, Reiki,
acupuncture or Healing Touch. Of the 25 patients, all had histories of
trauma of which 10 involved sexual abuse. 10 subjects had PTSD, 9 had
major depression, 3 had anxiety disorder and 3 had dual diagnosis. The
study concluded that the integration of complementary therapies into
community mental health practice may hold promise of enhancing mental
health outcomes and improving quality of life for long-term users of
mental health services.11
Another study conducted by four researchers at the
University of New Mexico concluded that "acupuncture provided large
treatment effects for PTSD, similar in magnitude to group CBT
(Cognitive Behavioral Therapy)", and it "may be an efficacious and
acceptable nonexposure treatment option for PTSD"12.
By
nonexposure treatment, we understand that the patients experienced
symptomatic relief equal to that of patients who participated in
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy but their treatment did not require the
self-disclosure that is normally part of talk therapy. This finding is
noteworthy for Rape trauma survivors because it offers patients the
option of symptom relief without the need to retell the tale of the
traumatizing event, which may be a preferred choice for some survivors.
Traditional Western treatment modalities for Rape
Trauma Syndrome include crisis counseling, psychotherapy and the use of
pharmaceutical drugs 13 to manage PTSD
symptoms 14, however use of and interest in
Complimentary Alternative Therapies (CAM) by treatment providers is
growing.
An informal survey of rape crisis centers around
the world revealed the following with regard to the use of
complimentary therapies as an adjunct to traditional (cognitive
therapy) oriented treatment. It should be noted that different centers
offer varying levels of intervention and service and this is reflected
in the array of responses. That said, when asked which therapies the
crisis center utilizes in the treatment of their clients, the following
answers were submitted:
- Talk therapy leading to EMDR (Eye Movement
Desensitization and Reprocessing 15).16
- Individual and group talk therapy, using a
variety of treatment modalities (i.e. CBT (Cognitive Behavioral
Therapy), DBT (Dialectic Behavioral Therapy), etc.) Also a yoga group
for survivors, that is a mixture of trauma-informed yoga practice for
grounding and reconnection, as well as group psychoeducation. In terms
of referrals, we refer to programs and practitioners that offer EMDR,
art therapy, and typically maintain referral information for
trauma-sensitive/trauma-informed massage therapists, acupuncturists,
etc. 17
- Peer-based support for sexual assault
survivors, their friends and family. One-to-one counseling, advocacy
and court support & accompaniment. Also body-mapping workshops for
survivors, as well as Circulo de Mujeres - Latin American women's
circle as a more holistic community based survivor support model. In
our work with incarcerated women/women in conflict with the law; we
have incorporated acupuncture as well as guided imagery and work with
oils. We have organized 'spa days' for volunteers offering massage,
acupuncture, juices - info on cleanse and detox. 18
- I am traditionally trained therefore,
Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy is the first choice to address issues
surrounding PTSD/Rape Trauma Syndrome. I also have training in DBT,
Adlerian, movement, and psychodrama. Basic expressive arts such as art,
poetry, music, and dance can be helpful when used as a tool to discover
what the client is feeling. One has to be certified as an expressive
arts therapist to use the expressive arts as a diagnostic instrument
tool. Therapy is always centered around the clients needs, and everyone
is unique. Therefore, every client I see receives a unique treatment.
Research has demonstrated a therapeutic connection between yoga and
trauma. I am trained in Yoga and have movement certifications. 19
- About your questions, we, Tokyo Rape Crisis
Center, do not offer any therapies. We can offer in house telephone
counseling only. When a client wants to know the information, we
provide it such as art therapy, group session or others. 20
- I read your mail and am sending you a rather
brief answer for the simple reason that we are not a therapy centre
(nor are the large majority of the other 8 centers in Israel). We have
a hotline which functions 24/7 and we offer our callers emotional and
practical support but not actual therapy. We can only refer our callers
to private therapists who specialize in treating sexual abuse and to
various other specialist centers, some supported by Social Services. We
also unfortunately, do not refer our callers to alternative therapy
practitioners as we have no way of examining their abilities or methods
and there are no official professional unions to whom we could refer
queries regarding specific therapists and their qualifications and
professional capabilities. We have had quite a number of complaints
from women who have been sexual abused by alternative therapists (also
by "regular" therapists – but in their case there is a possibility of
reporting to their official unions as well as to the police). I do not
in any way wish to give the impression that I do not believe in
alternative therapies but we personally cannot take responsibility for
referrals at this present time. Re-reading your mail, we do refer
our callers to art therapists who specialize in treating sexual abuse. 21
- We use a range of counseling therapies at
the NSW Rape Crisis Centre. These include Cognitive Behavioural
Therapy, Narrative Therapy, Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, and
Dialectical Behaviour Therapy. We only provide counseling services to
our clients and we do not have any staff who are qualified to provide
any other alternative therapies. While we provide referrals to other
counseling services and practitioners, many of our clients initiate
their own referrals to other services, which may also include
alternative therapies. We do not have any alternative therapies
practitioners on our database, but I am aware of some of our clients
also accessing Reiki healers, shamanic healers, acupuncturists, massage
therapists, attending yoga classes and hypnotherapists. As a feminist
service, we encourage our clients to make their own decisions about
what they would find helpful in their recovery. However, I personally
would encourage clients to be cautious when using any therapies or
practices that involve physical touch or having their eyes closed as
this can trigger trauma memories. I hope this information assists you
in your research. 22
- At the moment we offer containment
counseling on site at hospitals, crisis counseling over the telephone
and face-to-face at our three offices, support group counseling, court
support and paralegal advice and aromatherapy massage. We also offer
survivors an opportunity to speak publicly about their experiences as a
part of their healing process in our Speak Out project. 23
- Our Agency works closely with sexual assault
survivors supporting them through the police and medical process, and
supporting them in their transition to counseling which they can also
do through us. We work with what the client wants and needs and we talk
with them about the many different ways in which they may be able to
take care of themselves and ways that may help them to relax etc. We
will explore with them what might be helpful for them to try. Included
in those discussions certainly could be suggestions of trying breathing
therapy, massage, retreats etc. We don't offer any of these services at
our Agency but will certainly encourage the client to try different
things that may work for them. The client will often come up with their
own ideas of what they might like to try also. 24
- The rape crisis center does not offer
individual therapy. We refer the women to therapists outside the
center, according to their needs. Some of the places we refer to are
public services and others are private therapists that we know and
trust. The therapists are from different disciplines: dynamic therapy,
CBT, various methods of trauma therapy, art therapy, movement,
bibliotherapy, physical psychotherapy.
The support groups have been operating in the center for close to
fifteen years and they are facilitated by professionals from the
therapeutic field with a lot of experience in treating women who have
been sexually assaulted. The support groups are for survivors and
mothers of survivors.
Recently, we completed a course of a new group, which combined Yoga
with some verbalization. This group was created for women who had
already been in at least one support group in the past facilitated by a
Yoga teacher who volunteers in the center.
In light of the success of the first group and by popular demand from
the women, I am happy to announce that there is another Yoga group
starting now. 25
- We currently offer counseling for our
survivors free of charge. We also have a 24-hour crisis line available
for talking. We have hospital advocacy, court accompaniment,
information and referral. In all of our support groups, art therapy is
a component, especially with the younger age groups. There are not any
outside therapist we refer to primarily due to the lack of services in
our area and these services are usually too expensive for our clients
if they are offered. 26
- Initially I want to inform you that the Rape
Crisis Center of Milford offers peer counseling and advocacy to sexual
assault victims. There are no licensed therapists at the center. We are
all state certified sexual assault counselors and although we have had
training that includes the emotional dynamics of sexual assault
including but not limited to Rape Trauma Syndrome, we do not use
therapy techniques such as CBT etc. We do have a referral list for
professional therapists should it become necessary. This list includes
therapists who list trauma and sexual assault as part of their
experiences although I cannot say most "specialize" specifically in
this area. A fewer number of these therapists do specialize in
dissociative disorder. We also collaborate with mental health
professionals in our service area in a number of ways. This includes
mutually attended pre-scheduled meetings with the intention of
providing comprehensive care to clients and family members. This center
staff also attends trainings provided by various agencies and we
participate in cross training as well. To my knowledge none of these
therapists we refer clients to use alternative medicine to treat
victims of sexual assault although I have on occasion suggested some of
these alternatives to clients myself during counseling. As an advocate
for this center I can say that I am very interested in learning more
about alternative medicine such as you introduce to help with victim
recovery. It has actually been my intention to research this in our
service area to seek out therapists from our area who do use these
techniques but quite quite frankly have not had the time to do so. Ours
is a very small office with five staff people. I have had this topic
introduced several times recently and do intend to follow through. 27
- In general, referrals within the agency are
to licensed MFT, LCSW, PhD clinicians who must follow the standards set
in the field. If a client is interested in what is referred to as
non-traditional methods (yoga, meditation, body work, jin shin jtsu,
etc., we refer but are mindful of setting up legal complications if we
espouse to a technique that is not considered "standard practice" by
the western medical system. We are also EXTREMELY careful and mindful
of both the need for and the danger of hands on work of any kind - with
survivors who could be triggered. Also, we are beginning to embrace
"alternative" practices of yoga and meditation in the self-care of our
staff, who is exposed constantly to vicarious trauma... 28
The above responses reveal that among a small global sample, there is
an interest in, as well as concerns about integrative therapies for the
rape crisis centers' clients. The last respondent noted, there is both
a need for, AND a danger of hands-on-work with traumatized populations
since touch can have a "triggering" effect. This concern was addressed
in a Boston study, which involved the implementation of acupuncture
treatment program as a new service at an existing PTSD clinic for
refugees.
The authors write: At the start of the project,
several staff members expressed concerns
that due to the traumatic history of the refugees, the use of needles
would be an inappropriate treatment modality as it could further
traumatize the patients. To address this concern, we provided
acupuncture treatments for the staff so that they could make informed
decisions as to the appropriateness of the modality. All staff members
(n = 7) reported the treatments to be surprisingly relaxing and
enthusiastically referred their patients to the acupuncture clinic. In
fact, several of the staff members continued to receive weekly
acupuncture treatments to address symptoms related to secondary trauma.
Secondary trauma is an issue that commonly arises in refugee camps and
natural disaster sites where healthcare providers are exposed to
psychological trauma indirectly via exposure to the stories of his or
her patients.
In the end, the Boston study reported that 111
treatments were performed on 16 patients from 13 countries. While there
were no clinical measures taken, 14 of 16 patients self-reported a
reduction in symptoms. 29
The risk of retraumatization of sexual assault
survivors can also be addressed by providing treatments in a community
setting. Community Acupuncture 30 is a
relatively new model in the United States, in that treatment rooms are
typically set up with multiple tables or chairs in each room and
treatments are affordable (sliding scale). The community setting makes
it possible to avoid the scenario of a potentially nervous patient
being alone in a room with a practitioner if that scenario contributes
to the patient's sense of vulnerability. Concern may be raised about
the privacy available during patient intake, however it should be noted
that the details of the trauma need not be recounted in order for the
practitioner to be able to determine the correct course of treatment.
Describing symptoms such as: inability to sleep, fatigue, anger,
palpitations, etc. is sufficient for the practitioner to determine the
course of treatment. As an alternative to Community Acupuncture,
patients may seek treatments in a private setting and bring a relative
or friend into the treatment room. The buddy system may be used
throughout the course of the treatments, or until sufficient trust has
been established between patient and practitioner. This will of course,
not be practical for all patients, but it is an option that may work
for some.
For traumatized persons with histories of sexual
abuse it is interesting to note that an acupuncturist can choose from
hundreds of points on the body when designing a treatment. There are
many points on the body that treat regions of the body that are nowhere
near the affected area. For this reason, it is possible to use distal
points to affect areas of the body traumatized by sexual abuse. The
energy activated by the point SP4 (found on the medial side of the
foot) for example, acts upon the uterus. Distal points on the Liver
meridian, LV3, LV5 (between the first and second toes and on the medial
side of the calf, about 5 inches above the ankle) act on the areas of
the genitals. The hands, feet and ears are considered microcosms of the
body. This means that regions on the sole of the foot (as used in
Reflexology), on the dorsal and palmar surfaces of the hand (Korean
Hand Acupuncture) and the surfaces of the ear (Auricular acupuncture)
correspond to regions on other parts of the body. As such, it is
possible for a skilled practitioner to treat all areas of the body,
internally and externally through these "microcosms". When healing has
progressed and a greater degree of trust has been established between
patient and practitioner, it may be possible to mutually agree on the
incorporation of local points (points closer to the affected areas) if
needed. For example, UB32 is located over the 2nd sacral foramen and is
indicated for matters affecting the pelvis. CV17, which is in the
middle of the sternum regulates energy in the chest and can resolve
palpitations and irregularities with breathing.
Anecdotally, various newspaper articles confirm
that acupuncture has been and is currently being used to treat
populations suffering PTSD. An April, 2010 article from The Gainesville
Sun reported that the Academy for Five Element Acupuncture was offering
free treatment for veterans, active military personnel and immediate
family members. The article write: Reznek, a licensed acupuncturist,
said acupuncture is very successful in treating post-traumatic stress
disorder without any side effects. PTSD is an anxiety disorder common
to veterans 31.
The News Stories link on the website of the
organization: Acupuncturists Without Borders lists dozens of news
articles about outreach services that have been offered in response to
disasters which by their nature traumatize local populations as well as
first responders. Stories cover AWB outreach to survivors of Hurricane
Katrina, the Haiti Earthquakes, Southern California fires, and Veterans
outreach services. 32
Other news articles inform us of the use of
acupuncture in treating sufferers of Rape Trauma Syndrome. Since
October of 2008, St. Vincent's Hospital in New York has been offering
ear and now full body acupuncture treatments free of charge to
survivors of rape/sexual assault and/or survivors of childhood sexual
abuse/incest and their allies. 33 The radio
station 850 AM announced in August of 2008 that the Alachua County
Victim Services and Rape Crisis Center organized a twelve week
counseling and acupuncture program for five rape survivors. 34
As mentioned earlier, many of the symptoms of Rape
Trauma Syndrome (as well as those of the more general category of PTSD)
can be interpreted using the diagnostic language of Oriental Medicine.
Leon Hammer, M.D., L.Ac., has effectively "translated" the Western
diagnostic language of psychology into Eastern diagnostic language. Dr.
Hammer is a Western trained psychiatrist, a scholar, author and a
practitioner of Chinese Medicine. He is also the founder of Dragon
Rises School of Oriental Medicine in Florida. In his book, Dragon
Rises, Red Bird Flies 35 we learn that
anxiety, a common sequella to trauma, can be diagnosed as having five
causes according to the classical Chinese Medicine model. These causes
are:
- A combination of weak constitution and sudden
fright.
- Heart blood deficiency due to blood loss and
chronic disease.
- Internal retention of pathogenic fluids due to
Spleen and Kidney deficiency.
- Excess fire due to yin deficiency.
- Internal phlegm-fire.
Of course, identifying the exact pattern in a
given patient would
require a complete intake by a trained Oriental Medicine practitioner.
However, it is worthy to note that each classically defined cause for
anxiety points to the root of the problem according to ancient
diagnostic paradigms that are not commonly considered by the Western
model. As such, consideration of the Eastern diagnostic model along
with the Western view may lead to increased diagnostic accuracy and
treatment efficacy.
In chapter 13 of Dragon Rises, Red Bird Flies,
Dr
Hammer describes about 15 types of anxiety and depression
identifiable through Chinese medicine. This type of specific focus
allows for improved targeting of the treatment by addressing the
underlying cause of the depression or anxiety.
In another of Dr. Hammer's books, Chinese Pulse
Diagnosis: A Contemporary Approach 36 he
discusses the nuances of pulse diagnosis. In the index alone, the book
lists qualities we find on the pulse for stress, trauma, and emotions,
especially qualities unique to anger, anxiety, denial, depression,
despair, explosiveness, fear, guilt, horror, indecision, failure,
irritability, loneliness, rejection, melancholy, nervous tension,
panic, phobia, rage, reflection, repression, resentment, resignation,
labile emotions, sadness, spite, stress, suppressed emotions, tension,
terror, vengefulness, withdrawal, worry. For each of these emotions,
there are an average of maybe 10 qualities found on the pulse in
various combinations. (It is possible to distinguish some 80 qualities
in some 25 positions at 6 depths.) The indexes on trauma are also
exhaustive. That said, we can see that combining the Eastern diagnostic
with the Western model offers more to work with when assessing the
patient in order to select the most focused approach for treatment.
Amy Galvan, now a licensed acupuncturist working
with Rape trauma survivors in Florida shared with me the following case
study from the time that she worked as a student practitioner at Dr.
Hammer's school:
A patient's practitioner found pulse qualities
relating to vigilance, pushing her physical energy past its reserves,
excess sexual activity, guilt, old emotional trauma, spite and "Heart
Closed". The patient confided she had been raped years ago, but the
practitioner was able to see what no one else could see. The patient
was living a double life as a secretary by day and an entertainer by
night in the adult entertainment industry. When the practitioner
explained what she felt on the pulse and said this was common among sex
workers, the patient opened up and got the treatment she really needed,
which was for much more than her chief complaint of fatigue.
Dr. Hammer's paper entitled Trauma and Shock
in Chinese Medicine 37 explores the
concept of trauma as a causative factor in shock to the heart. In the
paper he describes the etiology, pathogenesis, signs and symptoms of
heart shock, leading to the diagnosis described as "Heart Closed", and
offers a case study and treatment. In this paper, he describes the
nuanced qualities found on the pulse that can lead to proper diagnosis
and treatment.
Additional case studies and treatment protocols
specific to survivors of sexual trauma (and other forms of "betrayals
of intimacy") can be found in Lonny Jarrett LAc's 38
lengthy 3-part journal article entitled: Chinese Medicine and the
Betrayal of Intimacy: The Theory and Treatment of Abuse, Incest, Rape
& Divorce with Acupuncture and Herbs. 39
40 Lonny Jarrett is a
practitioner of Oriental Medicine, a scholar and author who studied
under Dr. Hammer for a number of years, and was influenced by the
Contemporary Oriental Medicine lineage, which can be traced even
further back to Dr. John H. F. Shen, a teacher of Dr. Hammer's. 41
Written for an audience of Oriental Medicine
practitioners, Jarrett's article differentiates between various forms
of betrayal, and describes the psycho-emotional and energetic patterns
observed in patients who have experienced incest (pre-verbal and
post-verbal), rape, as well as divorce. For our purposes, we will focus
on incest and rape in our discussion. The distinction between incest
and rape is important in the following sense as explained by Jarrett.
In the case of incest, the victim has an expectation of intimacy from
the perpetrator. The violation happens before the age of 18, and often,
the trauma occurs before various social and/or developmental milestones
have been reached. Unlike rape, whereby the victim may already have
past experience in healthy intimacy and an awareness of healthy
boundaries, the incest victim often does not.
In the case of pre-verbal incest (occurring before
the development of language skills), an awareness of personal
boundaries had not even had a chance to develop, thus the legacy of the
trauma is particularly insidious. Jarrett writes that trauma at the
pre-verbal developmental stage can result in difficulty with acceptance
of nourishment in general. Treatment may be geared towards the organs
that deal with the assimilation and distribution of nourishment as
handled by the Small Intestine and Spleen 42 43.
The rape victim, on the other hand, experiences a
forcible crossing of an established boundary from the outer to the
inner. Oriental Medicine describes the outermost energetic boundary of
the physical body as the Wei Qi. The Wei Qi is seen as the body's first
line of defensive. It is the energetic barrier that protects us from
contracting external illnesses such as colds or other communicable
diseases, as well as the boundary that prevents events from emotionally
"getting to us". According to the OM model, the Lungs disperse Wei Qi
over the outer surface of the body, and the Triple Heater 44,
another
"organ" of Oriental Medicine, regulates homeostasis between the
inner climate and the exterior. Another energetic boundary is
maintained by the Pericardium, which protects the Heart from shock. A
rape victim may present with stagnant Qi in the Pericardium. This is
also described diagnostically as "Heart Closed", meaning that energy is
not allowed to reach the Heart. This can result in one of two common
scenarios, a Heart that builds up too much heat (reacting from old
injury by lashing out when someone tries to get too close), or a Heart
that has grown cold (lost passion for life). The treatment objective is
to restore the correct function of the Pericardium (also known as the
Heart Protector) so that the Heart can continue to receive nourishment
(and thus not grow cold), or, so that pent up energy, which generates
pathogenic heat, can be released from the organ, and the patient can
end the cycle of reacting to present situations from old hurts. In the
case of rape victims, treating the Lungs, Triple Heater and the
Pericardium may help repair the damaged boundaries on an energetic
level.
Another physiological manifestation of trauma is
what Jarrett calls a "Congealed Blood Pattern", which is essentially
the thickening of blood due to stored memories which have not yet been
fully integrated into the consciousness. When this pattern is detected,
treatment methods and herbal formulas, which invigorate the blood can
allow memories to resurface. Of the many herbal formulas available
within the pharmacopoeia of Oriental Medicine, Jarrett considers three
formulas to be significant.
Meridian Passage, a formula based on the classical
formula Shen Tong Zhu Yu Tang, now modified and formulated by
master herbalist and author, Ted Kapchuk 45
quickens blood and thus breaks up and moves "Congealed Blood". This
formula often allows old memories to resurface. Jarrett also uses this
formula with patients who feel that their memories are too painful to
allow them to surface. Jarrett informs us that his patients report that
the formula helped the memories to surface effortlessly and to leave
without getting stuck.
Yunnan Paiyao is a formula use to stop
bleeding and to treat Congealed Blood resulting from traumatic injury.
If the patient describes their heartache as having been "shot in the
chest" or "stabbed in the back", and also exhibits signs of drowning in
their own sorrow ("bleeding"), Yunnan Paiyao can alleviate the
piercing sensation in the chest (Congealed Blood), as well as help
contain the outpouring of emotions causing the feeling of being
overwhelmed. This in turn will help stabilize the patient so that they
may process and integrate the emotional material at their own rate.
Jarrett sometimes combines these two formulas to
help patients cope with memories. In the case of memories being stuck,
he administers Meridian Passage to quicken the blood, but if
this results in emotional overwhelm, he balances the treatment with Yunnan
Paiyao to restrain the emotional outpouring. This facilitates the
emerging and processing of difficult information at a rate that is
comfortable for the patient.
Finally, Sheng Mai San, a classical
formula also known as Generate the Pulse Powder, is used for
patients who have depressed Lung function and consequent Heart heat as
a result of having closed off the heart and suppressing lung rhythm due
to early trauma. The symptoms of this pattern would be felt as
heaviness in the chest with the heart carrying a heavy load inside. The
formula soothes the Lung, harmonizes the relationship between the Lungs
and Heart and ameliorates the feelings of loss that typically
precipitate this disharmony.
Jarrett tells us that in his clinical experience,
these formulas help patients with issues of betrayal regardless of the
time that has elapsed since the initial shock because the memory of the
trauma is stored or encapsulated within the energetic body.
The concept of encapsulated trauma is described as
a "Somatic Cyst Formation" and is further explored in a paper by Dr.
Michael T. Greenwood, MB, BChir, CCFP, CAFCI, FRSA titled: Psychosomatic
Compartmentalization;
The Root of Qi and Blood Stagnation. 46
The information contained in the paper is
especially relevant for Oriental Medicine practitioners who are in the
unique position of treating sexual abuse survivors who present with
Multiple Personality Disorders.
Another herbal formula that is worthy of
discussion is a Gui Zhi Jia Long Gu Mu Li Tang, which is
available as Cinnamon-D formula from Golden Flower Chinese
Herbs. In Golden Flower's Clinical Guide to Commonly Used Chinese
Herbal Formulas (5th Edition), it is noted that Ted Kapchuk, OMD states
that this formula is useful for sexual abuse survivors as well as
patients who have difficulty with intimacy, commitment and sexual
promiscuity. The Chinese medical actions of this formula, as described
in the guide regulate the yin and yang, harmonize the Heart and
Kidneys, restrains essence (Jing), harmonizes nutritive (Ying) and
protective (Wei Qi), and calms the spirit.
In the case of sexual abuse, the victim's
protective energetic barrier (Wei Qi) has been forcibly penetrated,
causing a leak of the nourishing energy to the outside. Since humans
communicate to each other energetically as much as verbally, this
"leak" of nutritive essence may invite further unwanted sexual
attention because the protective, containing barrier has lost it's
integrity from the trauma. This formula strengthens the body's
protective shield (Wei Qi), and consolidates (pulls towards the
interior) the nutritive essence (Ying and Jing), thus helping to
restore energetic integrity. Two herbs, Long Gu (fossilized
bone) and Mu Li (oyster shell), also found in the formula, calm
the spirit, which is another key aspect of bringing the patient into
balance.
The Heart/Kidney disharmony that the formula
addresses may be a consideration for patients who are emotionally
disconnected from the sexual experience due to past trauma. In Oriental
Medicine, the Kidneys govern sexuality and the Kidney meridian shares
points with the meridian called the Chong, which connects the uterus to
the heart. During sexual trauma, the victim may feel an internal
snapping, which can be likened to too much electricity running through
a circuit causing the circuit to burn out. The result of this severed
energetic connection, as experienced by the patient, would be the loss
of ability to experience the warmth of intimacy in the heart while
engaging in genital sexual contact. The deliberate severing of the
Heart/Kidney axis is one of the reasons that individuals forced into
prostitution are sometimes "broken" by their captors or pimps through
rape, in order to prepare them for the task of being able to "service"
(energetically nourish) clients without the "burden" of emotional
involvement. It is doubtful that pimps consciously realize that they
are severing a Heart/Kidney connection as understood in Oriental
Medical theory, however the concept that they are more likely cognizant
of, that of "breaking" their subject is as old as human history itself.
The concept of "breaking" or "breaking in" a sentient being, be it a
prostitute, a horse, a slave or a soldier is the forcible imposition of
the will 47 by the dominant party onto the
subordinate party, to destroy spiritedness 48
and make the master's will the will of the subject. As such,
reestablishing the Heart/Kidney connection is a critical aspect in the
healing of many individuals who have been sexually abused or exploited.
A point protocol that may be useful in the
treatment of rape trauma survivors is the clearing of aggressive energy
from the internal organs. In Oriental Medicine, various organs are
associated with specific, potentially deleterious emotions. The Lungs
with grief, the Liver with anger, the Kidneys with fear, the Spleen
with worry and the Heart with joy (of the manic type which is
considered harmful). These negative emotions are often associated with
trauma, and the aggressive energy protocol is one method that can be
used to drain this harmful energy from the organ systems and improve
the patient's overall emotional wellbeing. The protocol involves the
superficial insertion of needles along points on the back, which
directly affect the aforementioned organs, with the addition of the
Pericardium, which serves as a gatekeeper for energies entering the
Heart (this relates to healthy emotional boundaries). Departing from
the traditional protocol, when treating rape survivors, it may be
helpful to add needles inserted in the same style and with the same
intention over one or more of the sacral foramen as this is likely to
release trapped aggressive energy from the pelvic organs. The
traditional technique of draining aggressive energy is described
step-by-step in Lonny Jarrett's book Nourishing Destiny 49 along with detailed information about
pathogenic Qi in general, shock and trauma, as well as addictions as
they relate to the organs systems.
Another phenomenon that is described in ancient
Chinese medical texts, which is pertinent to this discussion, is called
possession. The aforementioned Dr. Greenwood writes in his paper titled
Possession 50
-"Although the concept is not acknowledged by modern Western medicine,
other medical, shamanic and religious traditions have long recognized
possession as a factor in disease." Individuals who have suffered
intense trauma or worked with survivors who have experienced the same,
be it from combat situations, serious accidents, the sudden or violent
death of a loved one, or traumatic rape, may describe the aftermath as
a feeling of being haunted by the event. Greenwood describes this
phenomenon as a Field Effect whereby the energy field of the body has
been fragmented due to the trauma and an exogenous energy form
(described in Chinese Medicine as Gui) attaches to the victim,
detrimentally affecting his or her quality of life. One way that a rape
survivor may experience this attachment, is in the inability to feel
clean despite repeatedly washing one's body. In Greenwood's paper,
classical and contemporary point protocols for the separation of the
parasitic Gui from the host are listed. These include the Internal and
External Dragons protocol as well as the use of Ghost points. While
such concepts are difficult to integrate into the Western scientific
model, and may even be discounted as outdated quackery or superstition,
these concepts and their treatments have been used empirically for
centuries.
To resolve the problem of empirical efficacy
without scientific validity, one group, the International Society for
the Study of Subtle Energies and Energy Medicine (ISSSEEM) 51, established in 1989, has been working
towards greater acceptance of the validity of subtle energy fields
through scientific research, publications and seminars for the purpose
of improving human health and advancing medicine worldwide. Through
their work and advocacy, they bring much-needed scientific credibility
to those ancient healing techniques, which have experienced a popular
resurgence in recent years, bridging the gap between scientifically
accepted therapies and those that have historically stood the test of
time, yet are only empirically proven, thus creating a more solid
integrated model.
Much of the suffering experienced by rape trauma
survivors exists in the realm of the invisible. In the case of physical
trauma such as a broken leg, an accident victim wears a visible cast
and will illicit compassion and aid from others. However, in the case
of rape trauma survivors, their injuries are often invisible to the
naked eye. As such, they will usually not receive the same support. In
fact, the outward expression of such a victim's symptoms may illicit
further societal shaming if the unresolved suffering results in
addictive behavior, emotionally labile expression, or psychological
disharmony, which is dismissed by some as simply being "crazy". It is
in this realm of the invisible, the realm where the injuries lie and
the realm in which Oriental Medicine has worked for over 3000 years
that we need to work to improve the lives of those who are suffering.
1 Burgess, Ann Wolbert
and Lynda Lytle Holmstrom. "Rape Trauma Syndrome". Am J Psychiatry
131:981-986, September 1974 doi: 10.1176/appi.ajp.131.9.981
2 Rape, Abuse, Incest
National Network; http://www.rainn.org
3 http://wonder.cdc.gov/wonder/sci_data/surveys/nhis/type_txt/nhis2002/althealt.pdf
(Viewed 7/10)
4 http://www.eftuniverse.com/
(Viewed 11/10)
5 http://www.tatlife.com
(Viewed 11/10)
6 http://www.tara-approach.org/
(Viewed 11/10)
7 http://zerobalancing.com/
(Viewed 11/10)
8 Allen JJB, Schnyer RN,
Hitt SK. The Efficacy of Acupuncture in the Treatment of Major
Depression with Women. Psychol Sci. 1998;9:397-401
9 Wang SM, Kain ZN.
Auricular Acupuncture: A Potential Treatment for Anxiety. Anesthesia
and
Analgesia Feb 2001;92(2):548-553.
10 Spence D, Kayumov L,
Chen A, et al. Acupuncture Increases Nocturnal Melatonin Secretion and
Reduces Insomnia and Anxiety: A Preliminary Report. J
Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci. 2004;16:19-28.
11 Collinge W, Wentworth
R, Sabo S. Integrating Complementary Therapies into Community Mental
Health Practice: An Exploration. J Alternative Complement Med. 2005;11:569-574.
12 Michael Hollifield,
Nityamo Sinclair-Lian, Teddy D. Warner, and Richard Hammerschlag,
Acupuncture for Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: A Randomized Controlled
Pilot Trial. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, June
2007.
13 A list of
pharmaceutical drugs used in the treatment of Post Traumatic Stress
Disorder can be found at: http://www.drugs.com/condition/post-traumatic-stress-disorder.html
- Viewed 6/2010
14 Chavez B. A Review of
Pharmacotherapy for PTSD. US Pharm. 2006; 31:31-38.
15 More info can be found
at: http://www.emdr.com/
- Viewed 6/2010
16 Joyce Callis from the
Greenville Rape Crisis and Child Abuse Center, Greenville, South
Carolina
17 Meg Bossong, from the
Boston Area Rape Crisis Center
18 Karlene, from the
Toronto Rape Crisis Centre
19 Teresa Preer, LPC, NCC
of the Rape Crisis Center of Horry and Georgetown Counties, South
Carolina
20 Yuko Fujisawa, Tokyo
Rape Crisis Center
21 Liz Halevy-Berger,
Haifa Rape Crisis Center, Israel
22 Julie Dombrowski, New
South Wales Rape Crisis Center, Australia
23 Kathleen Dey, Rape
Crisis Cape Town, South Africa
24 Sylvia, Auckland
Sexual Abuse HELP Foundation, Auckland, New Zealand
25 Shimrit Frenkel,
Jerusalem Rape Crisis Center, Israel
26 Shawna Mayo-Yokley,
Lifelines Rape Crisis Center, Mobile, Alabama
27 Cindy Dugan, Rape
Crisis Center of Milford, Connecticut
28 Rhonda James, MA, MFT,
Exec. Dir. Community Violence Solutions, San Pablo, CA
29 Pease M, Sollom R,
Wayne P. Acupuncture for Refugees with Posttraumatic Stress Disorder:
Initial Experiences Establishing a Community Clinic. Explore (NY).
2009
Jan-Feb;5(1):51-4.
30 More information about
the Community Acupuncture model can be found at: http://communityacupuncturenetwork.org
31 http://www.gainesville.com/article/20100426/ARTICLES/100429563
32 http://www.acuwithoutborders.org/awb_in_the_news.php
33 Tuesday Evening
Acupuncture Clinic For Survivors Of Rape &/Or Sexual Abuse And
Their Allies http://www.svfreenyc.org/event_883.html
34 http://www.am850.com/news/archives/2008/08/acupuncture_therapy_for_rape_victims.asp
- (Viewed 06/10)
35 Eastland Press,
Seattle, 1990, 2005
36 Eastland Press,
Seattle; Revised edition (December 1, 2005)
37 http://www.dragonrises.edu/articles/hammer-traumashock1.pdf
(Viewed 11/10)
38 Lonny Jarrett MAc is a
graduate of the Traditional Acupuncture Institute in Maryland (1986),
he holds a Masters degree in neurobiology from the University of
Michigan. He is a Fellow of the National Academy of Acupuncture and
Oriental Medicine. He has authored several books on TCM and is a
practicing acupuncturist and herbalist in Stockbridge, Massachusetts.
39 1995, Vol 23: American
Journal
of Acupuncture
40 Part 1 of this article
is also available online at:
http://www.spiritpathpress.com/chinese-medicine-books/articles/article_betrayal.pdf
Abstracts
of Parts 2 and 3 are available at the following two links: http://www.spiritpathpress.com/chinese-medicine-books/abstracts/abstract_betrayal2.pdf
http://www.spiritpathpress.com/chinese-medicine-books/abstracts/abstract_betrayal3.pdf
(Viewed 07/10)
41 http://www.insights-for-acupuncturists.com/dr-john-h-f-shen.html
- (Viewed 11/10)
42 The understanding of
the Spleen in Traditional Chinese Medicine is different from the
Western understanding of Spleen. In TCM, the Spleen encompasses the
western function of the pancreas, with additional functions. The Spleen
extracts essence from food, giving the material basis for Qi (life
force) and blood.
43 Organ names are
capitalized when discussed in terms of Traditional Chinese Medicine to
distinguish between Eastern and Western concepts, which can be quite
different.
44 The Triple Heater is a
conceptual organ, differing from the physical organs such as the Liver,
Kidneys and Heart. The uppermost "heater" governs the Heart and Lungs,
the middle "heater" the intestines and Spleen ad the lower "heater" the
reproductive organs and bladder. The Triple Heater is responsible for
homeostasis between these three levels of the body, and the body and
the exterior world.
45 http://www.kanherb.com/cons_pi_kanherbals.asp
(Viewed 11/10)
46http://www.paradoxpublishing.com/assets/files/publications/articles/aama/vol-13-1-compartmentalization.pdf
(Viewed 11/10)
47 will is the realm of
the Kidneys in OM
48 spirit is the realm of
the Heart in OM
49 pages 16-36, Nourishing
Destiny, 2003, 2006, Spirit Path Press
50Medical Acupuncture,
vol 20, Number 1, 2008, http://www.paradoxpublishing.com/assets/files/publications/articles/aama/vol-20-1-possession.pdf
(Viewed 11/10)
51 http://www.issseem.org
- (Viewed 09/10)
|